
The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is knowingly paying me too much local housing allowance because of a system glitch and it could have serious implications for my partner's immigration status.
I am entitled to shared accommodation allowance as I am under 35 and claim universal credit. However, the DWP is paying me the higher one-bedroom rate for couples.
Although we co-habit, my partner is an international student subject to immigration control and is not entitled to public funds. The DWP knows this, but insists a "recognised system defect" means it's unable to implement the correct calculation.
It told me that, until a technical solution is introduced, the system will continue calculating at the higher rate, and staff have been told not to correct accounts manually. It claims I will not be required to refund overpayments, but I'm more concerned about the wider implications for him.
Your concerns are understandable. For the past 18 months, you have been receiving the higher rate (now £790 a month) because your partner lives with you, instead of the £586 to which you are entitled. That's an overpayment of more than £3,600 and counting.
If someone subject to immigration control benefits from public funds to which they are not entitled, the Home Office could curtail their leave to remain.
You have been trying from the outset to correct the calculation. Your efforts were undermined by a tribunal last year which ruled your partner's living arrangements entitled you to the higher rate.
You appealed and in April another tribunal agreed a mistake had been made. It ordered your allowance be recalculated.
When the DWP failed to do this, you involved your MP. That's when you learned from the DWP of this extraordinary defect that prevents claims such as yours being automatically recalculated.
Even more extraordinary was the "operational guidance" preventing staff from making the changes themselves.
I submitted a freedom of information request asking how many claimants are affected and how much has been erroneously paid, but was told the information would be too expensive to collate. Almost certainly not as expensive as the sums being expended on ineligible recipients who do not wish to receive them.
I asked the Home Office whether the issue might compromise the status of people in your partner's situation, but it referred me back to the DWP. Despite having insisted it cannot manually override the system, the DWP did just that when I questioned it. It says: "We are aware of this issue, which involves an extremely small number of people. We will correct PJ's case so she receives the right amount, and are working to ensure customers do not experience a similar issue."
I was assured that no one will be asked to refund the overpayments.
We welcome letters but cannot answer individually. Email us at consumer.champions@theguardian.com or write to Consumer Champions, Money, the Guardian, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Please include a daytime phone number. Submission and publication of all letters is subject to our terms and conditions.